Law Messenger
Non-use cancellation of a trademark: risks for foreign rights holders start to materialize
25.03.2025
In 2025, the three-year grace period for the non-use of a trademark expires for many foreign right holders which exited the Russian market in 2022. This poses a risk of a non-use cancellation action against such trademarks from companies that continues to operate in Russia. Such precedents are already in place. One of such “fresh” precedents is discussed below.
In April 2022, the Swedish company Telefonaktiebolaget L. M. Ericsson (“Ericsson”), a major supplier of telecommunications equipment and the rights holder of Ericsson trademarks under Russian Registrations No. 205234, 207822, 253069 and International Registration No. 1024858, announced that it was suspending its activities and halted supplies of its equipment in Russia[1].
On 25 March 2024, R-Climat LLC (“R-Climat”), a Russian supplier of air conditioning systems, filed a claim with the Intellectual Property Court (“IPC”) for the early termination of a series of Ericsson trademarks in relation to goods of Class 11 of the NICE Classification (“devices for heating, cooling and ventilation”), the rights to which were owned by Ericsson (the “Ericsson case”).
R-Climat based its claims on Article 1486 of the Russian Civil Code, which allows to cancel a trademark for non-use at the suit of an interested party if the trademark has not been used for a continuous period of three years.
The IPC satisfied R-Climat’s suit, asserting that Ericsson had failed to prove that it had imported heating, cooling and ventilation devices under its own trademarks since 2021[2]. The IPC’s decision was upheld by the IPC Presidium[3].
On 25 December 2024, Rospatent accepted for consideration (but has not yet granted) R-Climat’s application for the registration of its own “Ericsson” trademark in relation to goods of Class 11 (“devices for heating, cooling and ventilation”).
Before this, Rospatent registered the “Ericsson” trademark in R-Climat’s name for goods of Class 25 (“clothing, footwear and headwear”). As we understand, that trademark was registered by R-Climat following the expiry of Ericsson’s own registration for “Ericsson” trademark in relation to Class 25 goods in 2022.
The IPC’s decision in the Ericsson case could create another negative precedent for foreign companies that have exited Russia, which claimants would be able to cite in similar disputes in the future. For instance, the Russian courts are already reviewing a number of cases involving the early termination of trademarks for non-use against brands that have left the Russian market (such as Starbucks[4]).
In our view, one argument that could be used in favour of protecting foreign companies’ trademark rights is the requirement under Article 1486 of the Russian Civil Code. Under the cited Article, a person challenging the protection of a trademark shall demonstrate its legal interest in cancellation of a trademark.
In the Ericsson case, the plaintiff (R-Climat) proved its legal interest by providing evidence that Class 11 goods had been manufactured at its request, and it had subsequently sold those goods.
However, if a claimant seeking the early termination of trademark protection for non-use is unable to provide relevant evidence of its legal interest, this may serve as a stand-alone ground to reject its claims[5].
It is also worth noting that in the Ericsson case the use of trademarks in relation to Class 11 goods ended before 2022 (when certain Russian counter-sanctions were imposed). In view of this fact, the IPC resolving the Ericsson case perhaps does not consider the matter of whether anti-Russian sanctions and Russian counter-sanctions should be viewed as a legitimate reason for the non-use of the trademarks. In some cases, however, Russian courts may take the view that the imposition of restrictive measures constitutes such a legitimate reason to dismiss the case[6].
Another argument to defend the interests of foreign rights owners in such cases may be based on Article 1483 of the Civil Code, which prohibits registering third party trademarks misleading consumers as to a product and its manufacturer or place of manufacture.
Legal Services
The B1 team is ready to advise you on any matters related to the protection of intellectual property, including matters concerning the early termination of a trademark for non-use.
Details
Show references
-
[2] Decision of the Intellectual Property Court of 30.10.2024 on Case No. SIP-334/2024
-
[3] Ruling of the Presidium of the Intellectual Property Court of 12.02.2025 on Case No. SIP-334/2024
-
[4] URL: https://kad.arbitr.ru/Card/0c78f9cc-256f-48f7-896b-3cf8afb98ae1
AUTHORS
Dmitry Semenov
B1 Director
Legal Services, Tax, Law and Business Support. Specializes in a broad range of intellectual property matters
Contact
Ivan Solonkin
B1 Staff
Legal Services, Tax, Law and Business Support
Contact
Restriction of access to fuel and energy data
Presidential Decree No. 686 dated 28 September 2026 “On Approval of the List of Information in the Fuel and Energy Sector Subject to Restricted Access and the Procedure for Its Use” entered into force on 28 September 2026 to establish requirements for using certain fuel and energy data. Decree No. 686 approves a list of information subject to restricted access, establishes a requirement to implement confidentiality measures and sets out the rules for its distribution and provision.
03.11.2026
Bankruptcy reform: new tools for business rescue
On 26 July 2026, Federal Law No. 253‑FZ was enacted, introducing substantial amendments to Federal Law No. 127-FZ “On Insolvency (Bankruptcy)” dated 26 October 2002. The Reform introduces new tools for business rescue, shifting the focus from forced liquidation towards preserving and restoring the solvency of distressed companies, both before and during bankruptcy proceedings.
28.09.2026
Identification of domain name administrators: what will change from 1 September 2026
From 1 September 2026, domain name administrators will be required to complete identification via the Public Services (Gosuslugi) portal. The changes introduced by Federal Law No. 569-FZ dated 29 December 2025 will apply to domain names with the extensions .RU, .РФ and .SU. A detailed identification procedure is expected to be established by the Domain Name Registration Rules, which have been drafted by the Ministry of Digital Development, Communications and Mass Media but have not yet been adopted.
27.08.2026
Bank deposits: changes to the temporary procedure for fulfilling obligations to foreign creditors
Effective 4 August 2026, the special procedure established by Presidential Decree No. 95 no longer applies to liabilities relating to deposits held by foreign individuals and Russia-registered structural subdivisions of foreign companies.
06.08.2026
Redomiciliation 2026: key changes introduced by the final version of Federal Law No. 319-FZ
Draft Law No. 1206580-8 “On Amendments to Article 5 of the Federal Law “On International Companies and International Funds” and Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation” was adopted by the State Duma at the third reading and approved by the Federation Council. Following the legislative process, it was enacted as Federal Law No. 319-FZ dated 4 August 2026. The final version of the Law on Amendments differs significantly from the original draft. We review the key changes introduced by the Law on Amendments, assess their impact on the redomiciliation process, and highlight practical implications for companies.
05.08.2026
Redomiciliation 2026: new rules, opportunities and risks for international companies
Analysis of Draft Law No. 1206580-8: how to secure and maintain international company status amid geopolitical constraints. Having passed its first reading, the Draft Law introduces fundamental changes to the mechanism for the redomiciliation of foreign legal entities to the Russian Federation under Federal Law No. 290-FZ “On International Companies and International Funds”. This publication explores key provisions of the Draft Law, assesses their impact on the redomiciliation process and highlights practical implications for companies currently undergoing or considering redomiciliation to Russia.
08.07.2026
Introduction of amendments to the corporate legislation: declaring a JSC or LLC board member as a removed one
Federal Law No. 237-FZ “On Amendments to the Federal Law ‘On Joint-Stock Companies’ and Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation” (hereinafter, the “Law”) was officially published on 4 July 2026. The Law specifies grounds when a member of the board of directors (supervisory board) of a JSC or LLC will be deemed as removed one before the expiration of his/her term and allows a company to elect new members to fill the vacant seats.
08.07.2026